[POLL] What Should Our Forum Moderation Policy Be?

[Rokio]

So, thanks to the Raiin thread, there have been questions raised about moderation of posts.  Some people feel that off topic/memey stuff like Exile's broccoli / circlejerk posts should be deleted.  Other people just want personal insults and fighty type stuff to be removed, since they feel it reflects poorly on the community.

Personally I feel like the minimum amount of censorship is best, but I'm willing to consider what that line should be.  So here's where you can vote and post arguments to support your opinion if you have one.

[John]

More moderation means less memes in every single thread not in the off topic section. You guys put this upon yourselves to create this persona for the jump community. The old tf2jump forums never had actual moderation aside from botspam clearing. I honestly do not see why we weren't able to control ourselves and stop posting random shit everywhere.

If you guys want the tf2 jump community to look good, handle your own shit and don't spew it on the forums.

In any case, we'll be looking for moderators if we do need actual moderation on this forum. More info in a different post if this really becomes a thing.

[Shunix]

i think if you censor people memes are you any better than SOPA?

just something to think about 

[Afterglow]

No moderation. Don't like the meme spewers? Ignore em. That's all you need to do.

[Grandpa]

Tyrannical rule is the only method, ban and delete any users/comments that disagree with the jump trinity + admins.

Trinity: Me, Afterglow, Alle.
Admins: Obvious, you know who you are.

[obsidiian]

I've pretty much let everything slide as long as it's not useless spam or something like it.  Some of the meme things are kinda dumb imo but whatever, you can post memes if you want because if someone doesn't want to see them they can just ignore them.

[flo]

Strong moderation.

It's always the same group of people who turn a normal topic into complete nonsens.

[.]

just ban internal, stone, scofield, flo etc and get it over with

[ReMaXeD]

Ecclesiastes 5:10 The Voice (VOICE)

Corruption often starts at the top and works its way down.


src
https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=Ecclesiastes+5%3A10&version=VOICE

[ST]

just ban internal, stone, scofield, flo etc and get it over with

you literally made one non troll post and now you think you're a saint lmao

[scofield]

No moderation. Don't like the meme spewers? Ignore em. That's all you need to do.

[scofield]

just ban internal, stone, scofield, flo etc and get it over with

how about they start with you, what do you think about that?

[ST]

I think that I get 5 people per week adding me asking if alle is black or not is a good ban reason 

[John]

I'll say this poll closes in a week. I'm counting strong and moderate moderation as one because they're essentially almost the same.

Might close down more if there is a significant amount of people wanting moderation

[.]

http://gyazo.com/e503b03d1eaa6998f8869011f9671199

most of ur fucking posts are in general discussion / serious threads. almost all of mine are in off-topic and/or not serious threads